Difference between revisions of "Keck Foundation LOI"

From Earlham CS Department
Jump to navigation Jump to search
 
 
(64 intermediate revisions by 5 users not shown)
Line 1: Line 1:
<pre>
+
\documentclass[12pt,letterpaper]{article}
Proposal
+
\usepackage{fullpage}
Introduction
+
\usepackage{url}
+
\textheight=9.0in
What we'll do
+
\textwidth=6.5in
Course Modules
+
\parskip 1.6mm
Test plot to examine ground flow and uptake
+
\pagestyle{plain}
Year round
+
\raggedbottom
Longitudinal
+
\raggedright
Off-site plot maintenence
+
\setlength{\tabcolsep}{0in}
+
\usepackage[small,compact]{titlesec}
Summer multidisciplinary research community
 
Continue maintence/development of local plot
 
Off-site plot research
 
K-12 teacher professional development workshops, prep for class
 
visits during the school year by those same teachers.
 
 
About Earlham?
 
  
Budget
+
\usepackage{pslatex}
Equipment:
+
%\usepackage{times}
Ultrasonic Nebulizer (Boorman?  Leave it here for now).  $15K
+
%\usepackage{palatino}
+
%\usepackage{palatcm}
Large freeze drier $20K
+
%\usepackage{helvet}
+
%\usepackage{bookman}
Acid digestion system $20K
 
 
Field monitoring equipment (one per location) ~$1.5K per, about 6
 
Temperature
 
Ph (digital)
 
Conductivity
 
Redox (reduction oxidation potential)
 
Computer, packaging, uploading
 
Nitrate selective probe through the summer?
 
 
Sampling equipment (what depth do we need?) $1K + lots
 
Lake sediment cores to 2m
 
Shelby soil cores to some unknow depth
 
One time install for monitoring wells and equipment for drawing
 
 
Sounds like different approaches for different locations.
 
Springwood has wells that we could sample (possibly)
 
 
Software and hardware $5K
 
Groundwater flow analysis -
 
Do we need cycles?
 
Talk to Mic about this
 
 
Workshop - ~$6K
 
Teacher stipends - 10 per workshop (year) over 4 years
 
Meals and supplies
 
Intructor stipends (or covered elsewhere?)
 
 
Supplies
 
Per faculty, per course, per student researcher
 
  
Faculty and student stipends for summer prep of curriculum modules
+
\begin{document}
  
Faculty Release Time during the academic year for first offering
+
\centerline{\large \bf Multidisciplinary Science Curriculum Modules and Student/Faculty Research}
+
Faculty and student Stipends for summer research projects based on this
+
\section*{Introduction}
  
What's the science
+
Earlham College requests \$342,400 to develop multidisciplinary science curriculum modules and student/faculty research projects focusing on a common core problem: metals in the environment.  This project will emphasize collaboration among our natural science departments, including biology, chemistry, computer science, geosciences, mathematics, and environmental science. Scientific research is becoming increasingly multidisciplinary and collaborative; therefore, it is essential to train our students to develop multi-faceted approaches to problem solving. This project will introduce an important scientific problem, ask students to collect and analyze data, and to make interpretations using different disciplinary perspectives in both coursework and independent research projects with faculty.  We believe this idea of collaborative multidisciplinary learning will transform our undergraduate curriculum in the sciences and provide a model for programs among the sciences at other liberal arts colleges.
Amount present over time
 
Take-up into tissue? Bioavailability
 
 
What metals
 
Mercury
 
Lead
 
Uranium
 
Arsenic
 
Selinium
 
Vanadium
 
Moly
 
 
What computational
 
Water flow through soil
 
 
Which courses
 
Harder to do entry level classes
 
EcoBio
 
Environmental Science and Sustainability
 
Programming and Problem Solving
 
Introduction to Computational Science
 
Statistics
 
Principles of Chemistry
 
  
Easier to do upper level courses
+
A grant from the Keck Foundation would support a modest amount of equipment, curriculum module and seminar development, and student/faculty summer research, over three years.  Curriculum modules will be created for both introductory and upper-division science courses.  Field, laboratory, and computational methods will be integrated in the modules for students at all levels to experience first-hand how modern scientific inquiry is carried out using a multidisciplinary approach.  Our study of metals in the environment will generate module and research topics reflecting faculty expertise, student interest, and local impact. Following the scientific and pedagogical success of this initial topic, we intend to expand it to reflect the changing interests of students, faculty, and the community.  We will study anthropogenic impacts on two local ecosystems: nearby Springwood Lake with documented pollution impacts from industrial activity and a site on campus.
Equilibrium and Analysis
 
Hydrogeology
 
Geochemistry
 
Modeling
 
Environmental Chemistry
 
Instrumental Analysis
 
  
Outcomes
+
Earlham College is a four-year, private, coeducational institution providing a liberal arts education for 1200 undergraduates.  In 2000, Earlham ranked eighth among 1302 institutions of higher learning in the Biological Sciences category of the Baccalaureate Origins Report.  One quarter of Earlham students major in science.  Earlham's teaching philosophy strongly emphasizes collaborative student/faculty research, both within courses and extracurricularly.  Earlham students regularly present papers at the annual Butler University Undergraduate Research Conference and at the annual Merck/Earlham College Undergraduate Research  Conference, and at national conferences in a wide range of science disciplines. Students are frequently co-authors on papers submitted to refereed scientific journals.
See how modern, collaborative, science is done
 
Outreach to local community, science in the context of real life
 
 
Why Keck?
 
Multidisciplinary curriculum development is hard to find public funding
 
for.
 
 
We'd like to keep up with the Joneses, and they all have Keck grants.
 
 
Modest size.
 
  
Items to Include:
+
Four aspects of our project work together to make it powerful: 1) our focus on local problems; 2) the combined use of field, laboratory, and computational methods;  3) the longitudinal involvement of students as they take introductory through upper-level science classes; and 4) showing students how modern science is multidisciplinary with teams of scientists who inform and illuminate the different disciplinary perspectives of a problem. 
How we are going to carry on after Keck's funding expires.
+
 
+
\section*{Description}
Weather station reference.
+
 
+
Curriculum modules relevant to this proposal will be incorporated into 6 introductory courses in 5 departments in the Sciences.  Almost every one of Earlham's 1200 students will take at least one of these classes before they graduate.  Additionally, curriculum modules will be incorporated into at least 7 upper-level courses in 4 departments in the Sciences.
Questions:
+
 
If we get funding from other sources can we be flexible about what we use  
+
{\bf Introductory Course Modules} - To illustrate how traditional topics can be introduced in an innovative way using this environmental project as a unifying theme, we propose to incorporate a new environmental chemistry component into our general chemistry class (typical annual enrollment of 90). This unit will introduce students to fate and transport modeling of metals by measuring the distribution coefficient, Kd, which is a common parameter used to estimate the concentration of metal pollutants in aqueous systems. Students will learn the significance of Kd, a measure of the soil sorption capacity, by determining this parameter in standardized material and applying the procedure to soils collected from our study sites.
their money for?
+
 
+
The module will be conducted over two laboratory periods. The first week will consist of a spectroscopy lab, where the students will be introduced to absorption spectroscopy for the determination of the metal concentration in water, and to infrared spectroscopy for the characterization of soil components.  In the second week, students will use atomic spectroscopy to determine Kd of one or more metals.  The effect of pH on Kd will also be investigated for the soils.  The results will be used to discuss such environmental issues as acid rain and metal mobilization.  The soil Kd results will be compiled in a database for use in fate and transport modeling.
What are our target locations?
+
 
One close to campus for ease of access for EcoBio, sample plot idea.
+
{\bf Upper Division Course Modules} - Hydrogeology serves to illustrate an application of our project to an upper-level course.  The lab modules for hydrogeology will target complete hydrogeologic characterization of both the on-campus research site and Springwood Lake. For the on-campus site, we will install ground water monitoring wells and multi-level piezometers. Subsurface hydraulic properties will be determined via constant-head slug tests and constant-discharge pump tests.  Quantitative analyses (using Earlham's Inductively Coupled Plasma spectrometer) will establish baseline metals concentrations.  Students will track the environmental fate of target metals added to the control site under regulated conditions. 
+
 
One further away that might be more "interesting": Springwood Lake,  
+
The proposed modules for hydrogeology will give students an experience that embodies much of the professional practice of the science.  Students will conduct all facets of the subsurface investigation, aquifer property determination, and sample collection. Students in other courses will cooperatively engage with hydrogeology students to develop the protocols for performing the environmental fate experiments, chemical analyses and equilibrium speciation modeling.  
Teal pond, Garner pond, Swayne Robinson/Richmond Gas Company, etc.
+
 
+
{\bf Summer Research} - Overall, we propose that the summer research component of this project will involve at least 6 faculty each year, about 18 projects total, and at least 36 students over three summers.
Tie to IDEM's/CIty of Richmond investigation of Springwood Lake? Mention
+
 
this.
+
Chemistry: collection, sample preparation and analysis of metals in a variety of environmental matrices, and the development and implementation of metal speciation protocols; investigation of the redox chemistry of soil; characterization and model synthesis of the metal-ligand complexes present in these soils/leachates.
+
 
Can we make the claim that taking a course with this module in it will  
+
Biology: sampling of aquatic biota (macrophytes and animals) in Springwood Lake to describe and quantify the food chains; evaluate the extent of bioaccumulation of metals by those organisms; assess the rates of biomagnification occurring in higher trophic levels.  
increase the chance that they will take another science course/major?  Is
+
 
there any support in the literature for this?  Survey students before and  
+
Geosciences: characterization of the physical properties of subsurface soils by conducting whole-soil hydraulic conductivity tests and laboratory grain-size analyses; determine reactivities of soil minerals by quantifying mineral constituents, cation-exchange capacities, organic matter content and surface functional groups.
after the class?  Survey classes without this module and with this module.
+
 
More other science courses are taken as a result of taking a course with
+
Computer Science: design, development, deployment, and management of the field monitoring equipment using photovoltaic panels, batteries, imbedded controllers, wireless data transfer interfaces, environmental sensors, and open source tools; modeling of the biochemical and groundwater processes.
this module?
+
 
+
\section*{Purposes, Aims, And Impact}
WWABD?
+
 
+
This project will bridge the gap between modern scientific research and science education by incorporating research modules into courses and further developing multidisciplinary summer research activity.  In addition to using multidisciplinary approaches in courses and research, we will institute a series of seminars for small groups of students who are enrolled in one of the courses with a research project module.  In these small groups, students will discuss and present the work their class is pursuing on the topic, and engage in weekly readings and assignments meant to broaden their understanding of the nature of modern, multidisciplinary science.
Documents to review:
+
 
Keck's mission statement, previous grantsAnswer the questions why Keck,
+
An important artifact of this project will be further development of Earlham's Environmental Studies program, which is largely staffed by the same faculty that would be a part of this work.
and why not someplace else.
+
 
+
Because this project will impact the local community, we will hold an annual poster session on-campus for the public in which faculty and students will present their results.  We believe this innovative approach of combining classroom scientific inquiry, summer research projects, multidisciplinary discussion, and community participation will give our students a unique opportunity to engage in truly modern collaborative science.
LOI guidelines.
+
 
+
\section*{Timeline}
References:
+
 
Report from Keck - Barbara
+
\begin{tabular*}{6.5in}{l@{\extracolsep{\fill}}l}
PITAC reports
+
Spring 2007 & Purchase and installation of equipment \\
+
Summer 2007 & Course module and seminar development, student/faculty research \\
Notes:
+
Academic 2007-08 & Initial implementation of course modules and seminars \\
Funding delivered Dec, 2006. Summer time is startup for both ongoing
+
Summer 2008 & Course module and seminar development, student/faculty research \\
research and course module developmentRelease the following Fall/Spring
+
Academic 2008-09 & Continued implementation of course modules and seminars \\
for first implementation in each course.  
+
Summer 2009 & Course module and seminar development, student/faculty research \\
</pre>
+
Academic 2009-10 & Continued implementation of course modules and seminars \\
 +
\end{tabular*}
 +
 
 +
\section*{Justification For Keck Request}
 +
 
 +
The costs involved in the proposed multidisciplinary project exceed the capacity of Earlham's operating budget.  In order to plan and implement this project, we must secure outside funding.  Private and government funding for multidisciplinary projects at 4-year colleges is limitedFurthermore, many focus on one core discipline with collaborative disciplines radiating from the core.
 +
 
 +
\newpage
 +
 
 +
\section*{Budget}
 +
 
 +
\begin{verbatim}
 +
                                  2007      2008      2009      Total
 +
PERSONNEL             
 +
  Faculty Stipends           
 +
    Summer research (@$600/wk) $28,800    $28,800    $28,800    $86,400
 +
    Project Coordinator        $3,000    $3,000    $3,000    $9,000
 +
  Student Stipends               
 +
    Summer research (@$400/wk) $38,400    $38,400    $38,400  $115,200
 +
 
 +
TOTAL PERSONNEL                                                $210,600
 +
               
 +
EQUIPMENT             
 +
  Ultrasonic Nebulizer        $15,000           
 +
  Large freeze drier          $25,000           
 +
  Acid digestion system        $25,000           
 +
 
 +
  Field Monitoring (4@$3000 each):            
 +
    Temperature, pH (digital), conductivity, redox (reduction oxidation
 +
    potential), pressure transducer, nitrate selective probe, computer,
 +
    packaging, and communications 
 +
  Total Field Monitoring      $12,000           
 +
 
 +
  Field Sampling:                    
 +
    Lake sediment cores to 2 m             
 +
    Shelby soil cores             
 +
    Monitoring wells (one time install)
 +
    Drawing equipment             
 +
  Total Field Sampling        $15,000
 +
 
 +
  Biology sampling gear        $3,800
 +
 
 +
TOTAL EQUIPMENT                                                  $95,800
 +
               
 +
SUPPLIES               
 +
  Per student (12) per year    $1,000    $1,000    $1,000  
 +
TOTAL SUPPLIES                $12,000  $12,000    $12,000      $36,000
 +
               
 +
GRAND TOTAL                                                    $342,400
 +
\end{verbatim}
 +
 
 +
In 2010, Earlham will be in the final stages of a capital campaign which includes support for an on-going summer student/faculty science research programThis endowment would continue support for the projects described in this proposal.
 +
 
 +
\end{document}

Latest revision as of 07:31, 31 January 2006

\documentclass[12pt,letterpaper]{article} \usepackage{fullpage} \usepackage{url} \textheight=9.0in \textwidth=6.5in \parskip 1.6mm \pagestyle{plain} \raggedbottom \raggedright \setlength{\tabcolsep}{0in} \usepackage[small,compact]{titlesec}

\usepackage{pslatex} %\usepackage{times} %\usepackage{palatino} %\usepackage{palatcm} %\usepackage{helvet} %\usepackage{bookman}

\begin{document}

\centerline{\large \bf Multidisciplinary Science Curriculum Modules and Student/Faculty Research}

\section*{Introduction}

Earlham College requests \$342,400 to develop multidisciplinary science curriculum modules and student/faculty research projects focusing on a common core problem: metals in the environment. This project will emphasize collaboration among our natural science departments, including biology, chemistry, computer science, geosciences, mathematics, and environmental science. Scientific research is becoming increasingly multidisciplinary and collaborative; therefore, it is essential to train our students to develop multi-faceted approaches to problem solving. This project will introduce an important scientific problem, ask students to collect and analyze data, and to make interpretations using different disciplinary perspectives in both coursework and independent research projects with faculty. We believe this idea of collaborative multidisciplinary learning will transform our undergraduate curriculum in the sciences and provide a model for programs among the sciences at other liberal arts colleges.

A grant from the Keck Foundation would support a modest amount of equipment, curriculum module and seminar development, and student/faculty summer research, over three years. Curriculum modules will be created for both introductory and upper-division science courses. Field, laboratory, and computational methods will be integrated in the modules for students at all levels to experience first-hand how modern scientific inquiry is carried out using a multidisciplinary approach. Our study of metals in the environment will generate module and research topics reflecting faculty expertise, student interest, and local impact. Following the scientific and pedagogical success of this initial topic, we intend to expand it to reflect the changing interests of students, faculty, and the community. We will study anthropogenic impacts on two local ecosystems: nearby Springwood Lake with documented pollution impacts from industrial activity and a site on campus.

Earlham College is a four-year, private, coeducational institution providing a liberal arts education for 1200 undergraduates.  In 2000, Earlham ranked eighth among 1302 institutions of higher learning in the Biological Sciences category of the Baccalaureate Origins Report.  One quarter of Earlham students major in science.  Earlham's teaching philosophy strongly emphasizes collaborative student/faculty research, both within courses and extracurricularly.  Earlham students regularly present papers at the annual Butler University Undergraduate Research Conference and at the annual Merck/Earlham College Undergraduate Research  Conference, and at national conferences in a wide range of science disciplines. Students are frequently co-authors on papers submitted to refereed scientific journals.

Four aspects of our project work together to make it powerful: 1) our focus on local problems; 2) the combined use of field, laboratory, and computational methods; 3) the longitudinal involvement of students as they take introductory through upper-level science classes; and 4) showing students how modern science is multidisciplinary with teams of scientists who inform and illuminate the different disciplinary perspectives of a problem.

\section*{Description}

Curriculum modules relevant to this proposal will be incorporated into 6 introductory courses in 5 departments in the Sciences. Almost every one of Earlham's 1200 students will take at least one of these classes before they graduate. Additionally, curriculum modules will be incorporated into at least 7 upper-level courses in 4 departments in the Sciences.

{\bf Introductory Course Modules} - To illustrate how traditional topics can be introduced in an innovative way using this environmental project as a unifying theme, we propose to incorporate a new environmental chemistry component into our general chemistry class (typical annual enrollment of 90). This unit will introduce students to fate and transport modeling of metals by measuring the distribution coefficient, Kd, which is a common parameter used to estimate the concentration of metal pollutants in aqueous systems. Students will learn the significance of Kd, a measure of the soil sorption capacity, by determining this parameter in standardized material and applying the procedure to soils collected from our study sites.

The module will be conducted over two laboratory periods. The first week will consist of a spectroscopy lab, where the students will be introduced to absorption spectroscopy for the determination of the metal concentration in water, and to infrared spectroscopy for the characterization of soil components. In the second week, students will use atomic spectroscopy to determine Kd of one or more metals. The effect of pH on Kd will also be investigated for the soils. The results will be used to discuss such environmental issues as acid rain and metal mobilization. The soil Kd results will be compiled in a database for use in fate and transport modeling.

{\bf Upper Division Course Modules} - Hydrogeology serves to illustrate an application of our project to an upper-level course. The lab modules for hydrogeology will target complete hydrogeologic characterization of both the on-campus research site and Springwood Lake. For the on-campus site, we will install ground water monitoring wells and multi-level piezometers. Subsurface hydraulic properties will be determined via constant-head slug tests and constant-discharge pump tests. Quantitative analyses (using Earlham's Inductively Coupled Plasma spectrometer) will establish baseline metals concentrations. Students will track the environmental fate of target metals added to the control site under regulated conditions.

The proposed modules for hydrogeology will give students an experience that embodies much of the professional practice of the science. Students will conduct all facets of the subsurface investigation, aquifer property determination, and sample collection. Students in other courses will cooperatively engage with hydrogeology students to develop the protocols for performing the environmental fate experiments, chemical analyses and equilibrium speciation modeling.

{\bf Summer Research} - Overall, we propose that the summer research component of this project will involve at least 6 faculty each year, about 18 projects total, and at least 36 students over three summers.

Chemistry: collection, sample preparation and analysis of metals in a variety of environmental matrices, and the development and implementation of metal speciation protocols; investigation of the redox chemistry of soil; characterization and model synthesis of the metal-ligand complexes present in these soils/leachates.

Biology: sampling of aquatic biota (macrophytes and animals) in Springwood Lake to describe and quantify the food chains; evaluate the extent of bioaccumulation of metals by those organisms; assess the rates of biomagnification occurring in higher trophic levels.

Geosciences: characterization of the physical properties of subsurface soils by conducting whole-soil hydraulic conductivity tests and laboratory grain-size analyses; determine reactivities of soil minerals by quantifying mineral constituents, cation-exchange capacities, organic matter content and surface functional groups.

Computer Science: design, development, deployment, and management of the field monitoring equipment using photovoltaic panels, batteries, imbedded controllers, wireless data transfer interfaces, environmental sensors, and open source tools; modeling of the biochemical and groundwater processes.

\section*{Purposes, Aims, And Impact}

This project will bridge the gap between modern scientific research and science education by incorporating research modules into courses and further developing multidisciplinary summer research activity. In addition to using multidisciplinary approaches in courses and research, we will institute a series of seminars for small groups of students who are enrolled in one of the courses with a research project module. In these small groups, students will discuss and present the work their class is pursuing on the topic, and engage in weekly readings and assignments meant to broaden their understanding of the nature of modern, multidisciplinary science.

An important artifact of this project will be further development of Earlham's Environmental Studies program, which is largely staffed by the same faculty that would be a part of this work.

Because this project will impact the local community, we will hold an annual poster session on-campus for the public in which faculty and students will present their results. We believe this innovative approach of combining classroom scientific inquiry, summer research projects, multidisciplinary discussion, and community participation will give our students a unique opportunity to engage in truly modern collaborative science.

\section*{Timeline}

\begin{tabular*}{6.5in}{l@{\extracolsep{\fill}}l} Spring 2007 & Purchase and installation of equipment \\ Summer 2007 & Course module and seminar development, student/faculty research \\ Academic 2007-08 & Initial implementation of course modules and seminars \\ Summer 2008 & Course module and seminar development, student/faculty research \\ Academic 2008-09 & Continued implementation of course modules and seminars \\ Summer 2009 & Course module and seminar development, student/faculty research \\ Academic 2009-10 & Continued implementation of course modules and seminars \\ \end{tabular*}

\section*{Justification For Keck Request}

The costs involved in the proposed multidisciplinary project exceed the capacity of Earlham's operating budget. In order to plan and implement this project, we must secure outside funding. Private and government funding for multidisciplinary projects at 4-year colleges is limited. Furthermore, many focus on one core discipline with collaborative disciplines radiating from the core.

\newpage

\section*{Budget}

\begin{verbatim}

                                 2007       2008       2009      Total

PERSONNEL

 Faculty Stipends             
   Summer research (@$600/wk) $28,800    $28,800    $28,800    $86,400 
   Project Coordinator         $3,000     $3,000     $3,000     $9,000 
 Student Stipends                
   Summer research (@$400/wk) $38,400    $38,400    $38,400   $115,200 

TOTAL PERSONNEL $210,600

EQUIPMENT

 Ultrasonic Nebulizer         $15,000            
 Large freeze drier           $25,000            
 Acid digestion system        $25,000            
 
 Field Monitoring (4@$3000 each):              
   Temperature, pH (digital), conductivity, redox (reduction oxidation 
   potential), pressure transducer, nitrate selective probe, computer, 
   packaging, and communications  
 Total Field Monitoring       $12,000            
 Field Sampling:                      
   Lake sediment cores to 2 m              
   Shelby soil cores               
   Monitoring wells (one time install)
   Drawing equipment              
 Total Field Sampling         $15,000
 
 Biology sampling gear         $3,800

TOTAL EQUIPMENT $95,800

SUPPLIES

 Per student (12) per year     $1,000    $1,000     $1,000  

TOTAL SUPPLIES $12,000 $12,000 $12,000 $36,000

GRAND TOTAL $342,400 \end{verbatim}

In 2010, Earlham will be in the final stages of a capital campaign which includes support for an on-going summer student/faculty science research program. This endowment would continue support for the projects described in this proposal.

\end{document}