Cs345-2008

Open Source Game Engine Reviews

Items to cover:

1. What are the capabilities and features - physics, rendering, sound, 2D/3D, scriptable or libraries.
2. Source langage(s), build language(s).
3. Maturity - how long has it been around? Are there lots of outstanding bugs? Are bugs getting fixed?
4. Are people using it? Do they cite examples? What does a Google search yield? CiteSeer?
5. What tutorials or sample programs are provided?

JIG - The Java Instructional Gaming Project

• Jig is a set of Java-based libraries designed to make it easy to incorporate game design and construction into undergraduate CS courses. One of the design goals was to make the abstractions such that it could be adopted at all levels of the undergraduate curriculum. This is an NSF funded project lead by two computer science professors and it appears most of the code was written by their students. It was first used in a class during the Fall of 2007 so the paint is still wet in a few places. They plan to publish a suite of curricular modules for professors to use when integrating JIG into existing courses.

1. 2D, library, Sprite Repository, Wiki with examples. No on-line mechanism to browse the library and no on-line call-level documentation so it's hard to tell exactly what capabilities it has.
2. Written in Java, callable from Java, built with NetBeans but it looks like Eclipse is supported too.
3. Not very mature, first and only release Fall, 2007. I could find one paper that referenced it, the one by the project leaders describing it.
4. The only people I can find using it are the authors.
5. Two tutorials, SpaceFrenzy and SuperSpaceFrenzy.

MotorEngine

• MotorEngine is in it's infancy. It has been publicly available for a week and has a status of pre-Alpha. It is the work of a single developer and is not in wide use. Sourceforge lists zero downloads so far and the largest application available that uses the engine is Hello World. According to the project's website: "MotorEngine is a 'work in progress' thing, so don't expect any outstanding features and be ready to deal with bugs (at this moment, at least). Also don't expect good documentation and cool tutorials. Don't expect anything... just use it :)"

• As this is our first experience in integrating a game engine into a project, I am under the opinion that we should choose one that has a larger community, better documentation, and has been around long enough to become usably stable. This project doesn't offer us much.

Crystal Space

• Crystal Space is an open source software development kit for game design and 3D graphics.

1. Contains modules for 2D and 3D graphics, sound, collision detection and dynamics via ODE and bullet (other libraries). It also contains a partner set of plugins and applications known as CEL (Crystal Entity Layer) that provides plugins for game dynamics such as camera handling, physics, movement and quest systems, etc.
2. Crystal Space is written in standard C++. It officially supports Linux, OSX, and Windows systems. CEL is written in C++ but can be interacted with through Python or Xml.
3. Crystal Space was first released in 1997. The latest stable release (version 1.2) occurred in October of 2007. Version 1.3 is currently in development. Crystal Space’s website contains an in-depth bug forum that uses the Trac system to allow users to report bugs. There are numerous listed bugs, but they are being fixed regularly. Crystal Space also provides a plugin for bug hunting called Bugplug.
4. Crystal Space appears to be one of the most frequently used open source game engines available. It appears on SourceForge, Google code, and numerous Linux-related sites.
5. There are seven basic tutorials and a few advanced tutorials for CEL and advice for artists. There is also a demo game called Crystal Core available for download.